Moving to Northern Colorado? 10 Towns Locals Complain About
If you live up here, you have heard at least one of these at a backyard barbecue: “Did you see my water bill?” or “I sat at the train for ten minutes.” Every town in Northern Colorado has the one thing locals complain about most, and if you are moving to Northern Colorado, those complaints matter, because a few of them show up in your monthly payment, your commute, or your resale value. Below are 10 towns and the gripe locals bring up most in each, loosely ranked by how much it can actually cost you, with what is real, what is overblown, and what it means if you buy there. If any of these towns is on your short list, our moving to Fort Collins guide is a good companion to this one.
Table of Contents
- Northern Colorado Towns At a Glance
- #10 Severance: Nowhere to Shop
- #9 Berthoud: The Parkway Merge
- #8 Timnath: Taxes and Cones
- #7 Loveland: City Hall
- #6 Fort Collins: The Train
- #5 Greeley: The Smell
- #4 Johnstown: Construction and Water
- #3 Windsor: The Data Center
- #2 Milliken: Water Bills
- #1 Wellington: Water, Always Water
- Frequently Asked Questions
Northern Colorado Towns At a Glance
| Town | The Complaint | Does It Cost You? |
|---|---|---|
| Severance | Nowhere to shop | ⚠️ Costs time, not money |
| Berthoud | The Berthoud Parkway merge | ⚠️ Annoyance |
| Timnath | Tax bill and constant construction | ❌ Metro district raises your payment |
| Loveland | City hall and the shelter debate | ⚠️ Mostly headlines |
| Fort Collins | The train horns | ⚠️ Noise near the tracks |
| Greeley | The smell | ⚠️ Comes and goes |
| Johnstown | Endless construction and rising water bills | ❌ Utility costs climbing |
| Windsor | The data center | ⚠️ A resale question |
| Milliken | Water bills that doubled overnight | ❌ Big monthly jumps |
| Wellington | Water, always water | ❌ High summer bills |
#10 Severance: Nowhere to Shop
Severance has grown fast, now listing a population over 10,600, but the retail has not caught up. Local guides describe it as a small community with peaceful streets and few businesses, and for most errands people drive about five miles south to Windsor. One Severance resident told CBS News Colorado he drives into Windsor just for groceries, and Windsor’s own town manager has said the King Soopers there became completely overwhelmed, which is why Windsor is now planning a second store.
Is the complaint overblown? Not really. If you want to walk to a coffee shop, Severance is not that town. But the trade-off is real: you are usually getting newer homes, quieter streets, and more house for the money than in Fort Collins. If you buy in Severance, budget time, not just money, because a gallon of milk is a car trip.
→ Related: Best Small Towns Near Fort Collins
#9 Berthoud: The Parkway Merge
This one is hyper-local, and if you live in Berthoud you already know it. Heading north on Berthoud Parkway off Highway 287, two lanes lead into a roundabout, and the right lane is supposed to turn toward Grand Market. Instead, a lot of drivers ride that right lane and cut left at the last second. Residents have called it dangerous in local traffic columns, and the town’s public works manager has acknowledged the complaints and the crash history.
So why has it not been fixed? The roundabout was built in 2018, and the town expected the vacant land on the east side to be developed by now, which would have required that developer to add a second northbound lane. The land is tied up in receivership after a partner dispute, so the permanent fix could be years away. Berthoud still has a small-town feel that is hard to find this close to I-25, but it is a good reminder that up here, road improvements are often tied to future development. Before you buy next to a vacant parcel, ask what is planned there and what it was supposed to pay for.
#8 Timnath: Taxes and Cones
Timnath is one of the fastest-changing towns in the area. Timnath Parkway has opened in phases, County Road 5 has a bridge and widening project, and the I-25 work permanently closed part of the East Frontage Road, so orange cones are part of the scenery. But the bigger complaint is the tax bill, and a lot of people blame the wrong entity. According to the Town of Timnath, the town itself received only about 4% of the average property tax bill paid in a recent year, roughly $215 out of a total near $4,950. The rest goes to the school district, the county, water districts, and, in many Timnath neighborhoods, a metro district.
That metro district is where buyers get surprised. These special districts pay for the streets, water, sewer, and parks in newer subdivisions, and they add their own mill levy to your bill, so two houses at the same price can carry very different monthly payments. If you are shopping in Timnath, ask for the actual tax bill and the metro district mill levy before you make an offer.
→ Related: Cost of Living in Fort Collins Colorado
#7 Loveland: City Hall
Loveland has had a rough few years at the city-government level, and residents on very different sides of the issues have been frustrated. Council meetings have packed out over transparency concerns and the financing of a multimillion-dollar downtown beautification project, but the biggest flashpoint has been homelessness. In September 2025, the city closed its only overnight shelter, a tent facility on South Railroad that the city said was always meant to be a short-term fix, and protesters turned out as crews began taking the tents down. Community conversations afterward described residents feeling frustrated and like they had lost trust, and in early 2026 a proposed new site on West 71st Street filled council chambers again.
What does that mean for you as a buyer? For most neighborhoods, less than the headlines suggest. Loveland still gets you more house for the money than Fort Collins, plus quick access to the Big Thompson Canyon and Lake Loveland. But if you are looking at a home near a proposed shelter site or a big city project, follow the council agenda before you buy, because those decisions can change what ends up next door.
#6 Fort Collins: The Train
You can love Old Town and still hate the train. The BNSF line runs right down the middle of Mason Street, past the CSU campus and along the edge of downtown, with a dozen street crossings. Federal rules require trains to sound their horns at crossings, so you hear it. The city has tried to fix this: it asked the Federal Railroad Administration for a waiver to create a quiet zone and was denied, then tested wayside horns that sit at the crossing instead of on the train. Today the city’s advice is to report long blocked crossings to the FRA, which collects the data, though the FRA itself says there are no federal rules on how long a train can block a crossing.
There are three railroads with tracks through Fort Collins, and the train is the complaint that surprises people most, especially buyers who fall for a house a few blocks from Mason. If a home is close to a line, go back at night and listen before you write the offer.
→ Related: What’s It Like Living in Fort Collins
#5 Greeley: The Smell
If you have driven into Greeley on the wrong day, you know. The reputation comes from the city’s cattle and meatpacking roots, with feedlots in the area and a large meatpacking plant in town, and geography makes it worse: much of the city sits in a bowl, so during temperature inversions the air, and the smell, settles in. Here is the part most people do not know. Greeley has been fighting this for decades. The city started an odor hotline back in 1995, complaints fell from more than 600 a year to just a couple dozen by the early 2010s, and the city even trained staff to measure odors with a handheld device called a Nasal Ranger.
So is the complaint overblown? Some days yes, some days no. The smell is real, but it comes and goes with the wind and the weather. What I would tell buyers is that Greeley gets judged by its reputation, and that reputation is part of why you can often get more house for the money there.
→ Related: Best Places to Live in Northern Colorado
#4 Johnstown: Construction and Water
Johnstown has grown fast, especially around I-25 and Highway 34. The town was very aggressive with annexations in the early 2000s, so there is a lot of land inside town limits and a pro-growth council and planning department. That is how you get Scheels, new neighborhoods, and orange cones everywhere. Johnstown has also been rebuilding its wastewater system, replacing an old lagoon-style treatment process from the 1950s with a new plant and bigger sewer trunk lines, and infrastructure like that has to be paid for somehow. This fall, Johnstown residents reported the same kind of high water bills that hit the town at number two on this list.
If you buy in Johnstown, you are buying into a town that is still being built. That is great for future shopping and services, but ask about utility costs, nearby planned development, and whether that view of open farmland is actually zoned to stay that way.
#3 Windsor: The Data Center
This is the newest complaint on the list. In September, Weld County commissioners voted 5 to 0 to approve a permit for a company called Global AI to run a data center on the former Kodak and Carestream site southeast of Windsor, after a hearing that ran roughly eight hours. It is a 41-acre project in unincorporated Weld County, and it could become the largest data center in Colorado. Residents near the site have raised concerns about noise, water use, and wildlife along the Poudre River Trail, while supporters point to jobs and property tax revenue, and plans call for a closed-loop, air-cooled system. After the vote, a citizens group began collecting signatures, reportedly tens of thousands, to put the decision to Weld County voters and require voter approval for future data centers.
Windsor is still one of the most popular towns in Northern Colorado, with Windsor Lake and a downtown that still feels like a small town. But if you are buying on the southeast side near the site, ask what has been decided since, and think about how future buyers might see it when you sell.
#2 Milliken: Water Bills
Milliken sits just east of Johnstown, and this fall it became the poster child for water-bill anger. The town switched to smart water meters, with roughly 2,500 installed by summer 2026, and then some August bills came in at double or triple the usual amount. One resident said his July bill was about $200 and his August bill was $450, and he learned he had been charged for extra days because billing months got lumped together. Town officials said three things stacked up: a 35% rate increase earlier in 2026 to fund water infrastructure, a summer drought with heavier lawn watering, and a smart-meter rollout they admitted was poorly communicated, and the town later acknowledged billing errors after one resident received a bill near $900.
For buyers, the lesson is not to avoid Milliken. It is that in smaller Northern Colorado towns, utilities are a real part of your monthly cost, and they can jump when a town catches up on infrastructure it put off. Ask the seller for a full year of utility bills. It is a simple request that can save you a nasty surprise.
#1 Wellington: Water, Always Water
Wellington takes the top spot because this complaint has lasted for years. Back in 2021, reporting showed the cost of new water infrastructure had pushed Wellington’s rates to the highest in Northern Colorado, and before the price, the complaint was the smell and taste of the water. In 2024, residents said their summer bills had soared past $700, with some past $1,000, and the town noted only a small share of residents fell into the highest usage tier. It came up again this past summer, when one resident said his bill went from about $103 in May to $160 in July, and the town’s deputy public works director said Wellington did not raise rates in 2026 and that the higher bills reflected heavier summer use.
So why do people keep moving to Wellington? Because it is one of the more affordable places to buy within a short drive of Fort Collins. The math just has to include the water. If you have a big lawn, ask the seller for summer bills, not winter ones, and think about xeriscaping before your first July.
Some of these complaints, like the Berthoud merge or the Fort Collins train, are things you will grumble about and get used to. Others, like the water bills in Wellington and Milliken or the metro district in Timnath, show up in your payment every single month, and that is the difference worth paying attention to. Every town up here has its complaint, and the smart move is knowing which ones cost you money before you buy. If a move is on the horizon, our moving to Fort Collins guide walks through the budget and neighborhood questions that make the final call easier.
Frequently Asked Questions
What do locals complain about most in Northern Colorado towns?
The complaints vary by town: Severance has little retail, Berthoud has a tricky parkway merge, Timnath has metro district taxes and constant construction, Loveland has had city-government and shelter controversies, Fort Collins has the downtown train horns, Greeley has the occasional feedlot smell, Johnstown has growth and rising water bills, Windsor is debating a large data center, and Milliken and Wellington have seen steep water bills. The ones that hit your monthly budget matter most when buying.
Which Northern Colorado towns have the highest water bills?
Wellington and Milliken have drawn the most attention for high water bills. Wellington’s rates rose with the cost of new water infrastructure, and some residents reported summer bills over $1,000 in 2024. Milliken saw August 2026 bills double or triple after a 35% rate increase, a drought, and a poorly communicated smart-meter rollout. In smaller towns especially, ask the seller for a full year of utility bills, including peak summer months, before you buy.
What are metro district taxes in Timnath and nearby towns?
A metro district is a special taxing district that funds the streets, water, sewer, and parks in newer subdivisions by adding its own mill levy to your property tax bill. In many Timnath, Windsor, and southeast Fort Collins neighborhoods, this means two homes at the same price can have very different monthly payments. Always ask for the actual tax bill and the metro district mill levy before making an offer, since the online payment estimate often misses it.
Is the Greeley smell really that bad?
It depends on the day. Greeley’s smell comes from area feedlots and meatpacking and is worse during temperature inversions because much of the city sits in a bowl. However, the city has worked on it for decades, running an odor hotline since 1995 and cutting complaints dramatically over the years. The smell comes and goes with the wind and weather, and the reputation is part of why homes in Greeley often cost less than comparable ones elsewhere in Northern Colorado.
What is the Windsor data center controversy?
In September 2026, Weld County commissioners approved a permit for Global AI to build a data center on the former Kodak and Carestream site southeast of Windsor, a 41-acre project that could be the largest in Colorado. Neighbors raised concerns about noise, water use, and wildlife, while supporters cited jobs and tax revenue. A citizens group gathered signatures to require voter approval for the project and future data centers, so the outcome is still unfolding as of this writing.
Which Northern Colorado complaints should actually affect where I buy?
Focus on the complaints that cost money every month rather than the ones that are simply annoying. High water bills in Wellington and Milliken, rising utility costs in Johnstown, and metro district taxes in Timnath show up in your payment year after year. Things like the Berthoud merge, the Fort Collins train, or the occasional Greeley smell are mostly quality-of-life issues you adjust to. Always ask for real utility bills and tax figures before you make an offer.
~ By The Levi Group Brokered by Real ~
Your Personal Guide to Fort Collins
Thank you for visiting our blog dedicated to what it is like to live in Fort Collins Co. We created all this content with you in mind. This site has the most comprehensive content about Fort Collins Colorado. If you have any questions please don’t hesitate to reach out to us. We would love to visit with you and answer any questions you have.
Jason Levi
The Levi Group Brokered by REAL, LLC
Call Me: 970-426-8916
Text Me: 970-426-8916
Email Me: jason@thelevigroup.net
Stay Up to Date – Subscribe & Follow
Youtube Channel: @LeviGroupNoco
Facebook: Jason Levi
Instagram: @noco.jas
POPULAR POSTS
VIDEO ABOUT FORT COLLINS COLORADO
Have Questions?
INSPIRATIONAL QUOTE
The Fort Collins Experience is your comprehensive guide to everything Fort Collins Colorado. Whether you’re searching for the best things to do, researching schools and neighborhoods, exploring local breweries and outdoor adventures, hunting for great restaurants and hotels, or staying up to date on Fort Collins real estate trends — you’ll find it all here in one place. This site was built with a single goal: to give you a genuine, firsthand understanding of what it’s really like to live in Fort Collins. As a longtime resident and full-time Realtor, I’ve walked these streets, explored these communities, and experienced every corner of this city. I share that local insight so you don’t have to spend hours piecing together scattered information like I once did. Whether you’re relocating, investing, raising a family, or simply curious, The Fort Collins Experience will show you why so many people are drawn to northern Colorado. Fort Collins isn’t just a location — it’s a lifestyle shaped by nature, community, creativity, and opportunity. If you’re ready to discover what makes Fort Collins Colorado one of the most desirable places to live in the state, you’re exactly where you need to be.

